EMMC module compatibility

Recently, I bought a Radxa UFS/eMMC universal module. According to the specifications, it should support both UFS and eMMC storage. I also purchased a Radxa UFS module and an Orange Pi 64 GB eMMC module.

The USB module works perfectly with the Radxa UFS module. However, when I connect the Orange Pi eMMC, it gets extremely hot very quickly, hot enough that I’m worried it may already be damaged. Unfortunetly I don’t have a Radxa emmc module to test if it’s compatible or no.

My first thought was that the issue might be incompatibility between different manufacturers. However, since both modules use the same standard socket, I’m unsure whether there is a pinout difference between vendors, or if my Orange Pi eMMC module might simply be defective.

Has anyone encountered this issue before, or can confirm whether Radxa and Orange Pi eMMC modules are pin-compatible?

The OPi eMMC module reserved pins are all ground, it can not work on Radxa SBC.

1 Like

Okay, I see, So reserved GPIO pins are being used for some logic (data/power line), while on Orange Pi they are used as ground. Can you confirm if this is also the case for Radxa USB stick modules?

From what I found online, the eMMC USB3 Reader can work with Orange Pi eMMC modules. So I’m assuming that Radxa UFS/eMMC modules might not support this and only work on Radxa hardware.

I’m wondering whether a trick, like using a hub or adapter that doesn’t connect the reserved pins, could make Orange Pi eMMC modules compatible with Radxa SBCs.

Confusing as it is, UFS module works with UFS USB adapter, and eMMC module works with eMMC USB adapter. One of them is using just one side of the module, the other is only using the other side.

I’m using Orange Pi eMMC modules on my Rock 5A, 5B, 5C without issues — those boards are incompatible with UFS though. Similarly, I wouldn’t be able to use this eMMC on my Orion O6N.

Yes, the socket is the same, and that adds to the confusion, but eMMC and UFS modules are not interchangeable.

2 Likes

Hi Ginkage,
I’m reaching out to you because I think you know quite a bit about EMMC modules.
I’m looking to buy an EMMC module and I found an interesting offer. Could you tell me if the EMMC specifications listed in the attached photos are compatible with a Radxa Rock 5C SBC?
Thanks.


It already claims to be compatible with 5B and 5A, so 5C shouldn’t be a problem. Generally, every eMMC module I had so far was compatible with all Rock 5 boards (there were some hiccups in early days, but those seem to be resolved by now).

Hi GinKage,
I think you are right. The HS200/HS400 (High Speed) models are compatible with the eMMC v5.1 module. I wanted to ask you because you have a lot of experience with this. In any case, I am going to buy this product and test it. I will check back later to let you know how it goes. Thanks again for your reply.

The thread has a useful contradiction: Jack says an Orange Pi eMMC cannot work on a Radxa SBC, but GinKage reports OPi eMMC modules working on Rock 5A/5B/5C. That points to the failure being specific to the Radxa UFS/eMMC universal adapter/reader rather than every Radxa board. Because the OPi module got very hot, I would not try a passive hub or pin-blocking hack without the exact pinout; use an eMMC-specific reader and, if possible, test the module on a known eMMC-only Rock 5 board first.